The Court Jester
  • Blog
  • Pop Culture Pulpit
  • Twitter
  • Videos
  • The Court Jester
  • About Eric B.

American Idol - Unlucky 13...?

3/9/2011

4 Comments

 
Picture
All right America - we got what we've said we wanted in year's past - we sifted through the 24th, 23rd, 19th, 17th - in one night last week - and now we have the top 13 going head to head, nice and slow-like. Song selections are from their own personal idol. Wonder how many J-Lo and Aerosmith songs we get… Here are my thoughts on each contestant, as always, typed before we hear what the judges say…

Lauren - Shania Twain's "Any man of mine" - I can't understand her first verse - no consonants! Not a fan of the camera blocking for her number. Hoping it's not a pattern. I like her a lot, but not my favorite of hers.

Casey - Joe Cocker's "A Little Help From My Friends" - I know this sounds crazy, but until the very end I felt like he was too reserved - I was imagining him doing better than he actually was. But again, how can you go wrong with the Beatles via Joe Cocker?

Ashthon - Diana Ross' "When You Tell Me That You Love Me" - Not a huge fan of this - it's not a great song - she's pretty and her voice is good and all, but  all that build up with the video piece made it seem like this note was crazy high, and it just didn't have that build for me.

Paul - Ryan Adams' "Come Pick Me Up" - I feel like he should have a "Jim Henson's" before his name. If anything, his performance suffers from not having enough of a live pub kind of mix in the house- needed more reverb, it's all very contained.

Pia - Celine Dion's "All By Myself" - Okay, so there's no question that she can sing the crap out of stuff - but every other part of her face, her stage presence, her body is so uninvolved - Open your eyes! I realize she's impressive already, but if she would let herself go just a little bit, it would be off the charts.

James - Paul McCartney's "Maybe I'm Amazed" - Great song, one of my favorites. He's great - will he go for the high notes? Do I have to ask? And he's in control of it - which is amazing - makes you realize how shaky Adam Lambert always was. Weird ending to the number, but I loved it.

Haley - Leanne Rimes' "Blue" - Check the difference here between her and Pia - both can sing for sure - but Haley tells a story with her song. And with her face. And I don't even like country music!

Jacob - R. Kelly's "I Believe I Can Fly" - No question that he's incredible - but today he was incredibly sharp. But unbelievably, it didn't matter. He's amazing.

Thia - Michael Jackson's "Smile" - I loved loved loved this until the beat kicked in, and then it was very odd to me. But what a pure voice quality.

Stephano - Stevie Wonder's "Lately" - I loved all the parts that weren't a disco inferno. Really, this was the best Stevie song to pick? All that modulation could make a person go blind…

Karen - Selena's "I Could Fall In Love" - interesting to sing an english cut of Selena's after impressing everyone bilingually… Not great for me - just kind of reveals a weak song - does this count as a J-Lo song?

Scotty - Do you think his idol is Ozzy? nope. Garth Brooks' "The River" - Seriously - he's so pure and solid - Did I mention before that I don't even really like country music? Am I being transformed?

Naima - Rihanna's "Umbrella" - Her first moves sent me back to a certain Neneh Cherry performance - she's great and all, but even this as interesting as it is, does not even compare to the earlier great voices. Great spectacle, but probably better when downloaded on iTunes.

Random notes:

Never been jealous of AI contestants until this year - getting to work with Jimmy Iovine, and Don Was… and all the Interscope peeps - wow.

Casey was a "rainbow of talent and a plethora of passion" - Steven Tyler('s writers).

So the judges went easy on that Diana Ross tune what with Barry Gordy in the house… respect. But you know they were thinking it.

Steven really loves to talk about how the "sum total" of [blank] has led someone to the [moment] - with interchangeable nouns. Wondering if he can sustain this 13 week stretch.

The product placement for Coke and Ford was bad, but the product placement for the mics and the sound equipment is even more annoying, because I don't know what the red letters stand for or what they are. Is that Dr. Dre's stuff?

So who is going home? My money is on Naima, but Ashthon is a close second. Or, I guess, twelfth.

4 Comments
ellie link
3/9/2011 08:42:46 pm

Charlie Chapman. Man. But we forgot about Eric Carmen.

I too liked Blue, and I liked James and I don't really like him. Kind of boring other than that, but I got some knitting done, so that's good...

Reply
pam
3/9/2011 10:50:14 pm

I love potential. This years group has the best potential EVER. My faves for the night were Casey, James & Haley. Lauren's performance was like she was still in rehearsal, a little too laid back & lacking. She's one of my faves tho. Casey just cracks me up. His mischievous personality reminds of Jack Black a lil' bit. Ashton, light as a feather. Meh. I hope she goes home tonite. Paul. Paul needs his guitar. I can't watch his stage moves. Maybe it's just me. Pia was robotic, indeed. Huge potential there tho, as soon as she gets out of her head. James, my fave. I love what the mentoring did for him this week - he still channeled all that energy & didn't overdo it! Haley - who knew she could sing country THAT well - uh oh Lauren! Jacob - waayyy too pitchy & screamy for me to enjoy. I was sad. Thia - so beautiful & sweet, yet struggled with pitch - (I was not smiling, sorry Thia). Stefano - didn't like the arrangement either, but I like Stefano. Karen - Also beautiful & sweet, but she put me to sleep. It's up to her fan base, but I wouldn't be surprised if she went home tonite. Scotty was Scotty. Good for Scotty. Naima surprised. She was better than last week by a mile, but was still struggled with some basics (like breathing) . Still, I think she proved she should be in the top 13, if only to do that Reggae breakout.

Reply
pam
3/9/2011 10:54:20 pm

and I "was still" struggle with grammatical editing. :P

Reply
Eric L link
3/10/2011 02:09:57 am

Last night was a bit tame all around for me. Pia can sing like an angel but she entertains like a stone.
To me James, Jacob, and Casey are the only true contenders.

I agree with the Casey assesment, I and many of my (non-musician) friends could have sung the first half better than that....snoooz-fest and looked a bit (dare I say) scared?
Jacob got pitchy but then he goes to those moments when he sings low and works through 5 octaves in 3 seconds and blows my mind.
James won last night for me, the control, the emotion, the highs, the in betweens. Anyone else hear a young Sebastian Bach there? Great pipes on that kid.

L8R All,

E

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Check It.

    Eric writes this blog, and twitters and stuff. That is all.

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    American Idol
    Art
    Christmas
    Epic Theatre
    Exponential
    Funny
    Harry Potter
    I Told You So
    Lost
    Music
    Musings
    Podcasts
    Pop Culture
    Story Conference
    Theatre
    Working At A Church

    Archives

    February 2014
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    August 2012
    July 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    September 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010


Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.